Mar 24, 2017 but while executive privilege may be on the ropes after several defeats in court over the years, history indicates that president donald j. Two centuries of white house scandals mitchell, jack on. These legal and constitutional principles, finelyhoned as they might be, are often overridden by the politics of the moment and practical considerations. No president could ever agree to allow the counsel to the president to go down and testify before a committee, nixon says. Executive privilege is the principle invoked in certain circumstances by the president of the united states and some other executive branch members. A brief history of executive privilege, from george washington through dick cheney at. Executive privilege is the constitutional principle that permits the president and highlevel executive branch officers to withhold information from congress, the courts, and ultimately the public. In the law of evidence, privilege means a right not to be compelled to give or produce certain evidence or answer certain questions or obey the commands of a subpoena. President trump checks his executive privilege the atlantic. In short, executive privilege is the right of the president and high executive branch officers when directed by the president to withhold information from those who claim a right of access to. Executive privilege legal definition of executive privilege. This article first appeared on hnn in december 2001.
President obama has invoked executive privilege to keep documents from congress about botched operation fast and furious. Executive privilege is the right of the president of the united states and other members of the executive branch to maintain confidential communications under certain circumstances within the executive branch and to resist some subpoenas and other oversight by the legislative and judicial branches of government in pursuit of particular. List of books and articles about executive privilege. Mark rozells executive privilege called the definitive contemporary work on the subject by the journal of politicsis widely considered the best indepth history and analysis of executive privilege and its relation to the proper scope and limits of presidential power. Executive privilege is also invoked to prevent executive branch employees or officials from testifying in congressional hearings. Jun 22, 2012 topics included obama administrations assertion of executive privilege in regard to attorney general holder and the fbis fast and furious. Executive privilege is an implied power claimed by presidents of the united states and other officials of the executive branch of government to withhold from congress, the courts or individuals, information that has been requested or subpoenaed. It is usually considered to be based upon common law rather than separation of powers, and its history traces back to the english crown privilege now known as publicinterest immunity. Introduction executive privilege is a concept invoked by members of the executive branch of the government to justify withholding evidence and other communicative materials from the legislative and judicial branches. Jun 01, 2010 executive privilege is confusing, and so this primer is meant to explain why some documents may not be disclosed, what the legal basis is for executive privilege, when it does and does not apply. I listened to the audio book edition of executive privilege by philip margolin on a long car ride what a great murder mystery. When presidents invoke executive privilege frontline pbs. President obama today invoked executive privilege to shield documents related to the fast and furious gun walking scandal from a congressional investigation, marking the first time his.
Mark rozells executive privilegecalled the definitive contemporary work on the subject by the journal of politicsis widely considered the best indepth history and analysis of executive privilege and its relation to the proper scope and limits of presidential power. Bushs attorney fred fielding has written karl roves attorney a letter instructing rove not to respond to subpoenas issued by the house judiciary committee. Jun 21, 2012 the facts behind obamas executive privilege claim. Buy a cheap copy of executive privilege book by phillip margolin. Topics included obama administrations assertion of executive privilege in regard to attorney general holder and the fbis fast and furious. Excerpt from an april 2012 article by jeff baker in the oregonian based on his interview with phillip margolin after the author had completed the final book in his washington trilogy featuring private detective dana cutler and fledgling lawyer brad miller.
President barack obamas assertion of executive privilege ahead of a hearing before a house committee, which subsequently recommended his. One oftcited definition comes from mark rozell, author of two books on executive privilege and the founding dean of the schar school of policy and government at. Jun 21, 2012 to my knowledge, executive privilege was first asserted by president nixon. Executive privilege raoul berger harvard university press. Presidential power, secrecy, and accountability studies in government and public policy third by rozell, mark j. When private detective dana cutler is hired to follow college student charlotte walsh, she never imagines the trail will lead to the white house. Generally speaking, executive privilege is the presidents right to withhold certain information from congress, the courts and most anyone else, even in the face of a subpoena. Jun 20, 2012 10 presidents who invoked executive privilege in recent history. Also held that executive privilege isnt absolute, but must yield when there are important countervailing interests 1. When presidents use executive privilege national constitution. Clinton was the first president to invoke executive privilege without issuing a written order. A brief history of executive privilege, from george. Watergate was a scandal that shook this country on the grounds that no one would have ever expected a president to be involved in such criminal activity. One oftcited definition comes from mark rozell, author of two books on executive privilege and the founding dean of the schar school of policy and government at george mason university.
In case youre rusty on executiveprivilege declarations in the past 50 years, the wsj compiled a list, using information from a 2008 congressional research service report. Chris calabrese is an intern at the national constitution center. On june 28, 2007, bush invoked executive privilege in response to congressional subpoenas requesting documents from former presidential counsel harriet miers and former political director sara taylor. Its a conditional privilege, meaning it can be overridden in some circumstances, such as when the president is the target of a criminal investigation. Mark rozells executive privilege called the definitive contemporary work on the subject by the journal of politics is widely considered the best indepth history and analysis of executive privilege and its relation to the proper scope and limits of presidential power. Presidents have the right to invoke executive privilege to preserve the confidentiality of information and documents in the face of. Executive privilege real and perceived newspaper in. Six decades of executive privilege the washington post. Under the doctrine of executive privilege, the president and important executive branch officers have the right to withhold information from congress, the courts, and, ultimately, the public.
At the 40th anniversary of the resignation of president richard m. He saved the country and congress a lot of time and grief by resigning. Most presidents have used executive privilege for reasons similar to president obamas. Congress has often chafed at white house refusals to reveal information, but has almost never seriously challenged a presidents use of. For me, much of the credit goes to narrator jonathan davis because i figured out who the murderer is right during the event. The white house may have tried to invoke its executive privilege to keep former chief strategist steve bannon from answering questions from the. Jun 21, 2012 in case youre rusty on executive privilege declarations in the past 50 years, the wsj compiled a list, using information from a 2008 congressional research service report. Executive privilege real and perceived newspaper in education.
But while executive privilege may be on the ropes after several defeats in court over the years, history indicates that president donald j. Jun 20, 2012 president barack obamas assertion of executive privilege ahead of a hearing before a house committee, which subsequently recommended his attorney general be cited for contempt of congress, sets. The politics of executive privilege law library of congress. Nixon, it is suitable that executive privilege be studied. The history of executive privilege is long but not deep. Executive privilege prior to nixons resignation, through all of the allegations that were made against him in regards to the releasing the tapes, he maintained the idea he did not have to release the tapes because he has the executive privilege. Executive privilege 101 center for american progress. Deliberative process privilege is a specific instance of the more general principle of executive privilege. President dwight eisenhower being the first to use the term. Congressional government 195, 198 meridian books 1956 1885. Jan 17, 2018 when can the white house use executive privilege. Indeed, it was one of only a few books that president bill clinton once selected for his. Every president, in some form, has invoked executive privilege.
Given the events of the last few days, it seemed like a good idea to rerun it. Introduction within american history, there has been many governmental scandals that have occurred, but one of the most notorious scandals that occurred was the watergate break, in which president richard m. A constitutional myth, raoul berger demonstrates that the presidential claim of authority to withhold information is without historical. When presidents invoke executive privilege frontline. Historically, presidents have claimed the right of executive privilege when they have information they want to keep confidential, either because it would jeopardize national security or because disclosure would be contrary. The right of the president of the united states to withhold information from congress or the courts. Presidents have the right to invoke executive privilege to preserve the confidentiality of information and documents in the face of legislative inquiries. Jun 20, 2012 clinton was the first president to invoke executive privilege without issuing a written order. Jun 20, 2012 history of presidential use of executive privilege. Where in the us constitution does executive privilege come. History, law, practice and recent developments summary presidential claims of a right to preserve the confidentiality of information and documents in the face of legislative demands have figured prominently, though intermittently, in executivecongressional relations since at least 1792.
Trump and future presidents will continue to call upon this powerand the courts will continue to judge its necessity. The doctrine of executive privilege has a long history and is controversial because it is nowhere mentioned in the u. President richard nixon believed about executive privilege that he, as president, had the right to withhold information from other government branches the legislative and judicial to preserve confidential communications within the executive branch and to secure the national interest. Congress had demanded that nixon release the watergate tapes.
Executive privilege is the right of the president of the united states and other members of the. Where in the us constitution does executive privilege come from. Executive privilege news newspapers books scholar jstor june 2009. The valid need for protection of communications between high government of.
Few such interbranch disputes over access to information have. The clinton administration in the courts neil kinkopf exploring the role of the judicial branch of the federal government in clintonera executive privilege claims, neil kinkopf suggests that courts have misunderstood executive privilege. This article examines one form of information control in the reagan administration. A unanimous supreme court decided against nixon, but did acknowledge that a qualified privilege exists. Indeed, it was one of only a few books that president bill clinton. These legal and constitutional principles, finelyhoned as they might be, are often overridden by the politics of. Executive branch positions on the scope of executive privilege. Eisenhower asserts executive privilege to thwart mccarthy. Bush and the case of executive privilege history news. Executive privilege is what some would call an airport novel or, a little less kind, a potboiler.
The white house may have tried to invoke its executive privilege to keep former chief strategist. Its all politics you wont find the term in the constitution, but its been a staple of presidents in one form or another since thomas. President nixon says he will invoke executive privilege to prevent white house counsel john dean from testifying at the confirmation hearings of fbi director l. What did president nixon believe about executive privilege. You can narrow or broaden the context of this timeline by adjusting the zoom level. List of executive actions by barack obama wikipedia. Bush also invoked executive privilege in refusing to disclose the details of vice president dick cheneys meetings with energy executives.
President carter invoked executive privilege to thwart an attempt by the general accounting office to investigate the claim. Mar 21, 2007 generally speaking, executive privilege is the president s right to withhold certain information from congress, the courts and most anyone else, even in the face of a subpoena. One oftcited definition comes from mark rozell, author of two books on executive privilege and the founding dean of the schar school of. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Jun 20, 2012 president obama today invoked executive privilege to shield documents related to the fast and furious gun walking scandal from a congressional investigation, marking the first time his. Jun 05, 2017 the history of executive privilege is long but not deep. In practice, executive privilege disputes between the white house and congress have often been resolved through deals to. Its all politics you wont find the term in the constitution, but its been a staple of. History, law, practice and recent developments summary presidential claims of a right to preser ve the confidentiality of information and documents in the face of legislative demands have figured prominently, though. There is a need for candor in communications, confidentiality, and this privilege flows from the enumerated powers c. The doctrine of executive privilege has a long history and is controversial because it. Books in the series are executive privilege, supreme justice. To better understand the executives stance in this area, this report will chronologically examine the development of the judiciarys approach to executive privilege and describe how the executive has adapted the judicial explanations of the privilege to support its arguments. Amending the civil service rules, executive order 488, and executive order 467 to modernize the executive branchwide governance structure and processes for security clearances, suitability and fitness for employment, and credentialing, and related matters january 17, 2017 january 23, 2017 january 17, 2017 82 fr 8115 201701623.
The united states constitution does not explicitly state that presidents may exercise the right. History of presidential use of executive privilege. Eisenhower was coined the phrase executive privilege, but wasnt the first president to invoke its principle. Congress can marshal its own impressive list of legal citations to defend legislative access to information, even when presidents assert executive privilege. Before you take that as a criticism, let me comment that there is a important need for. Thats probably not the neatest definition, but lets go with that for now.
1455 806 248 1342 41 46 1150 537 1035 356 490 524 644 947 1309 77 1475 272 267 160 419 1580 746 1555 122 1465 991 334 1246 1292 956 876 190 680 1132 291